One Year Review - Contractor Review
| Category: Highland House | 0 Comments
Well it has been about a year since we moved into the house. I wanted to post a contactor review because I have found that many people stumble upon the house blog while searching for information that I was once looking for. Hopefully this will help someone else out there.
We have had some issues with the house since move in time that I wanted to share on here. The first thing was a major item. Our yard failed to absorb water, and our curtain drain the county required doesn’t work as the country thinks. The county knew our yard had a poor absorbtion rate so I therefore paid for an extra large septic system with a curtain drain. It all works except for the fact that when it rains heavily (like this year at 110 year high rainfall), the curtain drain cannot drain all the ground water from the yard. This causes a problem when a septic system works by allowing the water to go to an absorption field in the yard. Because this is a hot topic with me, I’ll end by saying that Madison County really needs to do their job a little better. In the end I had to pay for a new system which the county would not allow me to put in the first time because they didn’t prefer them. I now have a typical Aeration system and have overpaid by almost $7,000 due to rework and additional requirements like lift stations that I would have not needed if Madison County let me put it in the first time. Thank you Madison County. They are not alone here though. Thank you planning and zoning of Highland for agreeing to allow our subdivision into city limits to tax us without requiring the developer to provide city services required (streets, storm drains, and sewers) and for not having a plan yourself to provide these services in the future. Thank you City of Highland.
Contractor Reviews
Framing and Concrete - K-Five Contracting Company
I cannot say one bad thing about this company. They showed up when they said they would, and worked every day until the job was done. The organization and planning of their crew was excellent. The quality of work has been great too. We have had no issues with their work, and if I were to build again, they would do the entire house.
Plumbing - Webb Plumbing - Collinsville, IL
Definitly cannot beat their price and they did all their work with great quality. Showed up every time I scheduled them too. Very easy to work with.
Heating and Cooling - Toennies Serivce Co - Damiensville, IL
They are the largest installer of Waterfurnance units, and they definitely have the savings associated with that. They were a very cost effective solution to using geo thermal. They weren’t the greatest at showing up when they said they were going to, but if you keep on them they work it out and get the job done for their original bid. Our geo thermal unit has had no major issues. The few issues we have had, they have immediately remedied or I have corrected them myself. We had a small leak through the foundation where the geo thermal tubes came in, but they just patched the area with some Hydro cement and all is fine.
Insulation - Blue Sky Insulation
They came and did all their work in one day as expected. They definitely put down plenty of cellulose and didn’t skimp on the attic areas where they easily could. Their prices beat the other large insulation company in the area, and they cleaned up after themselves well.
Lumber Supplies - UBC / Rehkemper Trusses
Very easy to work with and schedule deliveries. K-Five handled all the orders through my account and I did not have to get involved at all unless it was items I was ordering for other contractors. They worked with price matching and locking in prices once I was committed. They were able to compete eventually with Construction Supply prices to keep my business.
Roofing - Joiner Sheet Metal and Roofing / Gateway Roofing Supply
No complaints from them. They had a great price on the roof and gateway supply had competitive pricing on the materials. We have had many storms this year and record rainfall in the area (over 40 inches this spring). No issues with shingles or leaks.
Brick - Kohrmann Brothers
They definitely had a lot of work ahead of them. When shopping around and looking at brick on people’s houses, I really liked their work. It was clean and not sloppy. We wanted special features like window keystones, ribboning, and quoin corners. He did not charge ridiculous costs for those features. They did not show up directly when they said they would because of other jobs, but once they did get there, they stayed and workd on my house until they were done. Not like many contractors who start many houses at once. They made our stepped foundation look great.
Septic Install 1 - Hediger
The system and the price was good, the problem was my yard did not work. I think they should have been able to identify this a little better, but in the end their system technically worked, but the curtain drain did not work as the county said it would. The sad thing is all installers know this, but the county does not. I can’t blame them for the problems, but I would say that they should have a better idea of what will or won’t work based on soil analysis. The area I had for a septic system just kind of sucked.
Septic Rework - Ross Excavating
This was the installer I wish I would have found the first time. He dealt with everything. I didn’t have to mess with the county or permits. They took care of planning out the install and getting it to work. They were able to reuse many components to save me money, and did a great job on the work. They were always available and returned calls and very informative. Looked at every option and discussed them with us. System and work is excellent.
Drywall / Paint - J & R Drywall
They were the haggler of the contractors I had, always saying costs went up or this is extra, etc. I was still satisfied with their work, but this was kind of annoying. Their quality of finsihing work though is consistant and free of problems. It has been 1 year and I have no issues with cracks or other items people typically have with drywall after a year. When I go to finish my basement I will still call them. They left the house very clean after their work by covering all the sub floor with tar paper. They did spray my bathroom fans and some of my doors with mud, but I should have covered those as well. It was tough because we went on vacation while they did their work. Their paint job was completed nicely and I even had another painter comment on their edging with the ceilings. I was able to pre pay for my drywall which saved us some money and helped us out since the drywall costs were going up.
Doors / Windows / Trim - Windoor - Swansea, IL
We were overall pleased with windoor, but have had some issues that I still find annoying. Our basement door leaks. They came out and did replace all the weather stripping and re caulked it but I am still having some issues. Not sure where the problem is lying with that.
My huge annoyance with them though is ALL my exterior door frames have peeled all the way back to the wood. Windoor claims that because I did not paint them immediately, I left the door with the manufacturer primer exposed to the elements and this caused the issue. I think this is BS. No one paints a door before siding or anything is up on the house. The door has been sitting in their warehouse primed for who knows how long. They will not do anything about this.
Our screens for our Simonton windows suck. Not sure if these are truly simonton window screens or something Windoor gets, but they suck. They do not have tabs in them to install the screens from the inside, so you must install from the outside. They also are not snugly fitting into the windows, and have had 1 fall out from wind.
Trim had an issue with the paint when we first got it, but they brought us a new shipment of trim no questions asked. All stair parts were great quality and no issues with the products.
Final Grading / Seeding - J R Excavating
JR creates a beautiful yard, that is for sure. He didn’t cut any corners and used quality seed. Our yard looked so good right away it was amazing. After seeding the entire acre and watering, I have a small spot about 1 foot by 2 foot of thin grass. The rest of the yard is excellent and thick like it was sod. I will be calling JR back to re seed the yard torn up by my septic work for sure.